whoops1 It typed reply but I don't where I has gone! I really did think about angina, brienne! then I decided Dimsdale had either branded leter'A' upon his chest or cuased some other wound and that he was keeping them infected to fester and cause pain so he might suffer with hester. I don't know why he does not just confes and be forgiven by God, rather than live the lie and hypocracy that is literally driving him crazy.